Thursday, November 13, 2008

To Tom:

I'm surprised I let myself get so emotionally charged. It's unlike me. :) Ok, not that unlike me. But I do generally keep myself in check. I didn't think I'd get emotionally involved with Proposition 8. Just goes to show Satan has a hand in both sides of the debate. After this post, I'm backing down...but I must express my personal opinion...without emotion. I can do that because part of my opinion is based on fact.

But first, I let this slip in a comment I made on a recent online news article:

To Tom:
Then I want my marriage to my dog recognized so I can get a tax break and have a legal document proving my undying love to him...er, her. Heck (for the Mormon editor), does it even matter anymore? Why stop here? Let's legalize the marriage of 50 women to one man...or 50 men to one woman. Why not legalize the marriage of my 7 year old sister to the 49 year old man down the street? Why not legalize a brother and sister getting married? Why stop at same-sex marriages when there is SO MUCH more?
Peace.


Ok, that was my emotional part. Now to the factual portion of my opinion.

Marriage is an institution ordained by God. It is His law. And no man has the right...let me rephrase that...no man has the authority to override the laws of God. You can question, you can oppose, you can fight against God...but consider the state of our fallen brother, the morning star, even Lucifer.

Marriage is defined by God. It is not a right. It is not a privilege. It is a commandment. The first commandment to Adam and Eve was to multiply and replenish the earth. That can only be fulfilled through the sanctity of marriage between a man and a woman. God sets the rules. It is His law.

Two men or two women can love each other. They can live together. They can even be married...they have been doing so for years. Proposition 8 doesn't change any of that. It does not discriminate nor does it take agency (the freedom to choose) away from any individual. It simply declares that marriage is defined as the union of one man and one woman. It doesn't eliminate anyone's "right."

I'm not saying there is an easy solution. I don't know what government's involvement should or should not be. I do not understand the appropriate "legal" response to this issue. But I do know God's interpretation of marriage. His prophets have made it clear to me.

In 1995, it was stated: We, the First Presidency and the Council of the Twelve Apostles of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, solemnly proclaim that marriage between a man and a woman is ordained of God and that the family is central to the Creator's plan for the eternal destiny of His children. It goes on to declare: We warn that individuals who violate covenants of chastity, who abuse spouse or offspring, or who fail to fulfill family responsibilities will one day stand accountable before God. Further, we warn that the disintegration of the family will bring upon individuals, communities, and nations the calamities foretold by ancient and modern prophets.

This isn't just a "gay-rights" issue. It's about protecting the sanctity of the family. And those who currently have families are held to a higher standard...so I'm certainly not condemning those who have a same-sex partner. I have dear friends who are open and honest about their same-gender sexual preference. I respect them as individuals and love them as I do any other friend. I don't treat them differently...I don't talk behind their back...I am open and honest as well. And I'm supportive. We all need a little more of that.

I am standing for what I know to be true. Marriage is ordained of God...He sets the standards and I am striving to abide by them. Proposition 8 aside, that is where I stand.

3 comments:

Cheryl said...

Here here! I have also been tied up in knots over the whole thing, and I'm not sure why. I have ties to CA on both sides of the issue, and I have been surprised at my response. You have worded things so well, and I agree wholeheartedly with it all. I feel like copying and pasting it and hanging it on my door...

Laurel said...

amen to everything. and here's my take...this is about preserving a definition...not changing it.

I can't claim to be a mother/parent and have a child if I don't have one. If I want to be a parent, in the truest sense of a word I either have to get pregnant or I have to adopt. That doesn't mean I'm being discriminated against.

If marriage means "man+woman", why can't civil union mean whatever else? Heterosexual means "man & woman"...and no one is offended by that? Where will it end?

Anonymous said...

I believe Prop 8 actually does take away the freedom of same-sex marriage in the state of California (unless I'm mistaken). So in that sense it is a gay-rights issue.

I too believe marriage ordained of God is between a man and woman. I do have one question for you though. Do you believe someone who is gay here on earth will not be gay after their earth life? Do you think their spirit will change and all of a sudden they will be heterosexual? I just think we all need to be careful how we talk about this issue. I understand the Mormon church view of marriage and no one is taking that view away from them. A Mormon marriage in the temple is ordained of God. No other marriage is, right? Til death do us part, right?

I believe there is much we do not understand and will not understand and each person has a right to not be discriminated against. It is easy to make blanket statements about gay rights and gay marriage. I would be curious to what your gay friends feel about the issue. Walk a month in their shoes.

I for one do not believe the government should be involved in social decisions.

I have many friends who are gay and many who have left the church because they felt there was no place for them so I am quite passionate about this issue. Thanks for making me think again...